da Vinci Robotic Surgery Lawsuit: Is Robotic-Assisted Surgery a Double-Edged Scalpel?

Comments · 124 Views

It's important to remember that while robotic-assisted surgery has a promising future, challenges still need to be overcome. These difficulties include the price of robotic systems, moral dilemmas, restriction


Robotic-assisted surgery is a sophisticated form of minimally invasive surgery that employs robots under computer control to complete tasks that people are unable to complete or to produce superior results. A surgeon who has completed robotic surgery training performs the procedure. When the first robotic surgery was performed in 1985, robotics were being used to reduce movement brought on by hand tremors. Robots offer stability, accuracy, integration with modern imaging breakthroughs, a broader range of motion, and telesurgery, among many other benefits unique to each surgical specialty. Surgeons that utilize the robotic system discover that it enhances flexibility, control, and gives them a better view of the surgical region as compared to traditional approaches.

According to information from the equipment makers, there were approximately 644,000 robotically assisted surgeries performed in the United States in 2017. The US performs more medical procedures using robotic assistance than any other country in the world. Additionally, 65% of all da Vinci robotic devices used globally and 73% of all robotically assisted cases performed globally take place in the United States.

There were 600,000 robotically assisted surgical procedures performed in the United States in 2022. By 2028, there will likely be a significant increase of 1 million procedures in the robotic surgery market.

Robotic assisted surgery is a technique that uses instruments that are carefully controlled by a qualified surgeon. The surgeon console, where the surgeon sits to operate the instruments in high-definition 3D, is the essential part of the robotic surgery system.  The next one is the patient cart, which is equipped with a camera and other tools that the surgeon can control from a console. The vision cart, which facilitates communication between various parts and supports a 3D high-definition vision system, is another crucial element.

Now let's look at the advantages that patients receive from having robotic surgery.

       Less bleeding

       Lessening of pain

       Less use of medicines

       Less scarring

       Fewer infections at risk

       Shorter hospital stays

       Quicker recovery times

Who is responsible for a botched robotic surgery?

When performing robotic surgery, the surgeon still has a responsibility to provide the greatest standard of care and to use the technology correctly. The patient must show that the risk of a robotic malfunction would have been reduced if the procedure had been carried out at a different facility or by a different surgeon when a robotic-assisted surgical error results in injuries or any other damages.

The robotic surgical system known as the da Vinci Surgical System is produced by Intuitive Surgical Inc. Four robotic arms make up the robotic system. Robot-assisted operations used in the da Vinci surgical system have had unfavorable effects and caused difficulties for many patients.

In 2014, the business issued a recall for specific cannulae parts because of the potential for misuse-related degradation that could endanger patients undergoing robotic treatments.

In March 2017, during a da Vinci robotic inguinal hernia surgery, a patient's intestines allegedly had to be severed. This was discovered when the patient left the hospital two days later. The patient came back, complaining of stomach ache, and later died that day. In both federal and state courts in the United States, patients have brought thousands of claims.  The impacted victims attempted to combine the lawsuits into a multidistrict action in 2012. The U.S. Judicial Panel on Multidistrict Litigation rejected the application on the grounds that there weren't enough claims to support a consolidation. The corporation has put aside $17.4 million as of the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission report from March 2018 to settle the lawsuits. Most lawsuits are known to be discreetly resolved outside of court. Intuitive Surgical yet maintains that there is no risk of harm.